Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Regina Farr on May 14, 2008 at 8:52am

I think it's ok to share credentials and if you receive an interest to then get back with the candidate to get their approval before sharing their resume. As recruiters we must remember we have a responsiblity to our candidates to handle their information professionally. Just my thoughts....

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Claudia Faust on May 14, 2008 at 9:03am

Hi Rami,

You'll probably get a variety of responses to this question, but only because there are no formally established standards. My perspective is that it is rude and presumptive to share a resume without specific permission of the candidate, and doing so perpetuates the image of the Ugly Recruiter. It is such a small courtesy to ask the preference of the candidate, and sends a clear message that you acknowledge the candidate is in control of his or her own job search. It also takes you out of the spam loop by ensuring that you're making meaningful connections in your network.

Just my .02,
Claudia

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Rami Madi on May 15, 2008 at 3:42am

But how passive candidates sourcing will work if we need to make sure all candidates approve their referral. Sometimes I am paid to provide the contact information for 50 candidates in a specific industry, I can’t call everyone to make sure that they are willing to share their information or not. I don’t see any harm if the other recruiter contacted them to offer them a job position, which might be their dream job.

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Rebecca Griffin on May 15, 2008 at 9:25am

It is not ethical to pass along someone's credentials without their permission. In the world of VMOs, or MSPs, this action often results in double submissions. Many people do this with out the candidates knowledge, while they are working legitimately with someone, speaking to them about positions and this could potentially prevent them from getting an opprtunity the fair way.

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Karen Mattonen CAC CSP on May 15, 2008 at 11:43am

As usual I bring up what many are not aware of - Legally in MOST states in America, one MUST obtain Permission From the candidate Before Sharing their Electronic Data with a third party.. Data could include their email address - fyi

Also, we also should have a wonderful disclaimer on our sites which demonstrate what we do with their data (Privacy Disclaimer) -- ever noticed that ALL professional business sites have one.. think they do this because it is fun? and they are just being nice?

For the Business aspect of it all -- Now come on Guys, we are supposed to be Professionals Here! These Candidates entrust us with their information, and do hope that they want to be in charge of what is happening to their data, and that they have control of what is being sent, and to whom

This is shoddy behavior and it is definitely not professional, and it gives us a really bad name

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Claudia Faust on May 16, 2008 at 2:40pm

Ok, so are you talking about passing around a resume, or sharing someone's name and email address with a recruiter you know and trust, or making lists of candidate information available to recruiters in the public domain? You can see how each of these scenarios has its own set of landmines relating to privacy and consent to disclosure.

The most sensitive issue for the passive candidate may be related to this: the implication that they are in active job search mode when they did not consent to be there. At best, this can be an irritant to the candidate; at worst, it can cause professional embarrasment leading to loss of personal credibility or even their job (and yes, I saw this happen once along the way -- and no, it wasn't pretty for the candidate or the recruiter who caused it).

I recommend you go the extra mile to build and keep a stellar reputation as a recruiter. Share information intelligently with others, and assume as little as possible about the desires and motivations of everyone in the loop (this means candidates, hiring managers, and other recruiters). When in doubt, ask a question; it won't hurt you, and may lead to more business than you know what to do with.

I love that you're asking these questions, Rami -- it shows that your "internal compass" is pointing in a good direction.

▶ Reply to This